After 4 Nations it became apparent to me that the All-Star game needed a change and with my background in event creation and tournament organizing from working in esports, I decided to give it a shot myself. I originally finished my idea around late March of this year, but only put it all down in a PowerPoint pitch deck. After some free time over the summer I decided to put it into an article style format. For those wondering I will be talking about the new All-Star changes at the end of my article. Please enjoy.
The Idea: Split NHL players into 8 teams based on birthplace. (4 NA & 4 EU) in a Winner Takes All tournament. Starting roster sizes: 8F, 4D, 2G.
Team Makeup:
- Canada East & West
- America East & West
- Europe East (Belarus, Latvia, Russia)
- Europe Central (Czechia, Germany, Slovakia, Switzerland)
- Sweden-Denmark
- Finland-Norway
Format:
A Group Stage will be held to determine seeding. Stating with two groups one in North America and the other in Europe. Games in the Group Stage will be 3-on-3 with 10 minute periods until the end of the Group Stage. Once the Group Stage ends, elimination games begin. The winning teams will pick 2 forwards and 1 defenseman from the losing the team. Semi-Final games will be 4-on-4, with 15 minute periods and a roster size of 10F, 5D, 2G. The Final game will be a full 5-on-5 game with normal 20 minute periods and a full NHL roster size of 12F, 6D, 2G. All games are best of 1. Ties at the end of regulation will be determined by 5 Min OT and a shootout if needed, except for the Semi-Final and Final.
| Group Stage Locations | QF and SF Locations | Finals Location |
| NA (Seattle, Calgary) | NA (Detroit, Buffalo) | Toronto or Montreal |
| EU (Bern, Prague, Budapest) | EU (Riga, Copenhagen) |
- Climate Pledge Arena (Seattle), Scotia Place (Calgary)
- PostFinance-Arena (Bern), O2 Arena (Prague), MVM Dome (Budapest)
- Little Caesars Arena (Detroit), KeyBank Center (Buffalo)
- Xiaomi Arena (Riga), Royal Arena (Copenhagen)
As you might have already put together, we start out West in North America and move East. In Europe we start in Switzerland and move East before going North to Latvia and finishing in Denmark. Know lets take a look at a possible schedule.
Trade Freeze: Jan 30st 2029 – Feb 12th 2029.
Dates:
Feb 1st
– NA Media Day & Travel day for EU players
Feb 2nd
– EU Media Day & Game Day 1 NA (1v2,2v3,3v4)
– Final Travel Day For EU Players
Feb 3rd
– Game Day 1 EU (1v2,3v4)
– NA Travel to Calgary, EU Travel to Prague after
Feb 4th
– Game Day 2 NA (1v4,1v3,2v4), EU (1v3,2v4)
– EU Travel to Budapest
Feb 5th
– Game Day 3 EU (1v4,2v3)
– EU Travel to Riga, NA Travel to Detroit
Feb 6th
– Day Off
Feb 7th
– Game Day 4 NA (S1vS4,S2vS3), EU (S1vS4,S2vS3)
– EU Travel to Copenhagen, NA Travel to Buffalo
Feb 8th
– Game Day 5 NA (SF1vSF2), EU (SF1vSF2)
– EU Travels back to NA, NA Travel to TOR/MTL
Feb 9th
– Day Off (maybe Skills Comp)
Feb 10th
– Final Game
Now I know what you’re thinking. What would some potential rosters look like for these teams? Well I threw some together for you just for the sake of seeing what they could be in 2029.
Eastern Canada All-Stars
F: Nathan MacKinnon, Connor McDavid, Mitchell Marner, Brad Marchand, Sidney Crosby, Wyatt Johnston, Mark Scheifele & Beckett Sennecke.
D: Matthew Schaefer, Evan Bouchard, Thomas Chabot & Noah Dobson.
G: Scott Wedgewood & Jet Greaves.
Western Canada All-Stars
F: Brandon Hagel, Brayden Point, Seth Jarvis, Macklin Celebrini, Connor Bedard, Jordan Eberle, Gavin McKenna & Dylan Cozens.
D: Devon Towes, Cale Makar, Josh Morrissey & Travis Sanheim.
G: Darcy Kuemper & Joel Hofer
Eastern American All-Stars
F: Kyle Connor, Jack Eichel, Alex Tuch, Matt Boldy, Jack Hughes, Clayton Keller, Trevor Zegras & Ryan Leonard.
D: Quinn Hughes, Adam Fox, Jackson LaCombe & Zach Werenski.
G: Jake Oettinger & Joey Daccord.
Western American All-Stars
F: Matthew Knies, Auston Matthews, Jason Robertson, Brady Thachuk, Tage Thompson, Matthew Thachuk, Jake Guentzel & Troy Terry.
D: Jacob Slavin, Seth Jones, Jake Sanderson & Neal Pionk.
G: Dustin Wolf & Jeremy Swayman.
Central European All-Stars
F: Leon Draisitl, Martin Necas, David Pastrnak, Kevin Fiala, Tim Stutzle, Juraj Slafkovsky, Marco Rossi & Dalibor Dvorsky.
D: Roman Josi, Moritz Seider, Filip Hronek & Simon Nemec.
G: Karel Vejmelka & Philipp Grubauer.
Eastern European All-Stars
F: Kirill Kaprizov, Aliaksei Protas, Nikita Kucherov, Matvei Michkov, Danila Yurov, Ivan Demidov, Pavel Dorofeyev & Vitali Pinchuk.
D: Alexander Nikishin, Aytyom Levshunov, Dmitri Simashev & Alberts Smits.
G: Ilya Sorokin & Arturs Silovs
Finland-Norway All-Stars
F: Artturi Lehkonen, Aleksander Barkov, Mikko Rantanen, Michael Brandsegg-Nygard, Sebastian Aho, Kaapo, Kakko, Benjamin Rautiainen & Anton Lundell.
D: Miro Heiskanen, Henri Jokiharju, Esa Lindell & Emil Lilleberg.
G: Juuse Saros & Ukko-Pekka Luukkonen.
Sweden-Denmark All-Stars
F: Ivar Stenburg, Leo Carlsson, William Nylander, Nikolaj Ehlers, William Eklund, Lucas Raymond, Oscar Fisker Molgaard & Anton Frondell.
D: Philip Broberg, Rasmus Dahlin, Victor Hedman & Erik Karlsson.
G: Filip Gustavsson & Mads Sogaard.
Now lets tie everything up with a Q&A and address the new All-Start format for 2027.
How are teams made?
Teams are made up from players’ birth location or hometown. For Canada and the USA it would be best to define a line that splits the population of NHL players so that East and West side represent 50-50 of their NHL player populations. Exceptions may apply to a player like William Nylander who was born in Calgary but is known to play for Sweden so he may be a part of the Sweden-Denmark team. And if a player outside of NA or EU is voted in we can make adjustments to the teams requirements. Fans can vote from a list of player who they want to see play. A captain will be assigned to each team, they will choose the players they take from the other teams during the elimination games.
Will PWHL players participate?
This entirely depends on if schedules align. I for one think the PWHL should have its own All-Star game, but for the sake of the argument let’s say they do. I think each team would get 1 player with the same rules applying for selection based off birth place. However, they would only play in the group stage so that
1) They aren’t away from their PWHL teams for too long. & 2) So final rosters remain 12F, 6D, 2G.
Why are so many games in the EU?
There are equal amount of games in the EU so that the NHL can generate more revenue and grow the game more in Europe by showing off its European talent. It would do good to spread the game as much as possible while the NHL seems to plan on expanding again very soon.
Are Russians allowed to play?
Yes, Russian players are allowed to play as this isn’t an international competition representing a single country, this is an All-Star game representing NHLers from all over the world and those from Russia are welcomed to play.
Why can’t European teams be made up of one country?
The simple answer is that it makes representation from more European countries easier. Both Sweden and Finland could have their own teams but it’s about celebrating as many NHLers as possible. On top of making it easier to have 8 teams participating.
Skills Competition?
I think after 4 Nations it really showed that the Skills Competition is a really outdated concept and with NHL Edge we can see all the interesting aspects of fastest skater and harvest shot. That being said you could host it on the day before the Final Game.
What do the winners get?
This is TBD maybe a large sum of money (maybe even a charity donation to the winners choosing) but the 4 Nations trophy could be used for this event.
Finally the NHL announced on June 2nd, 2026 that a new format for the All-Star will be introduced. At a first glance its a good step in the right direction. They are capitalizing on the success of the 4 Nations event by using 5 Nations (1 being the Rest Of World). However, I think if they are obviously playing it safe. I want them to go a step further, it needs to expand. An All-Star Weekend isn’t going to get the same amount of engagement and attention. Expanding to 8 teams and playing games across NA & EU, they will be able to sell more tickets and make the event more worthwhile. All while keeping it a similar length of break in the season that the Olympics causes to keep the schedule consistent every year would be a good thing. That being said, I’m excited to see how the 2027 All-Star event goes.
That concludes my concept for the 2029 All-Star game. Thank you for spending the time to read it if you made it this far.
